Planet Rugby

  • The Best in 2010

    The IRB have announced the nominees the 2010 Player of the year award.

  • Missing Men

    Can you guess England's class of 2006 that won 23-21 against South Africa..?

  • November Tests

    Get all the news, views and interviews from the end-of-year tours.

  • Loose Pass

    The latest edition of our weekly column about all things rugby...

Ireland battle past Samoa

13th November 2010 16:32

  • Email
    • Add to del.icio.usDelicious
    • Add to DiggDigg
    • Add to Redditreddit
    • Add to FacebookFacebook
    • Add to StumbleUponStumbleUpon
Ronan OGara

Fifteen points: Ronan O'Gara

Ronan O'Gara scored fifteen points, including a try, as Ireland battled their way to a 20-10 win over Samoa in Dublin on Saturday.

Ireland ended their six-match losing streak but will remain deeply concerned by their deteriorating form after struggling to dispatch the visitors.

It was not until his O'Gara's 66th-minute try that the Irish, who entered the match as much as 1/66 favourites, took control.

Number eight Jamie Heaslip crossed in the first half to help them into a 10-0 lead that was pegged back by a touch down from winger Alesana Tuilagi.

Facing their weakest opposition of the autumn and a team ranked outside the world's top ten, they toiled woefully in the third quarter.

Had Samoa made better use of their enormous superiority in possession and territory, Declan Kidney's side would surely have been facing a second defeat of the month.

The Irish scrum, anchored by props John Hayes and Tom Court, were overwhelmed in a department where they were supposed to have the ascendancy.

It was only when Cian Healy and Rory Best came on that the set-piece was sured up and it was this change in fortunes that preceded O'Gara's try.

But the result fails to mask the fact that less than a year from the World Cup Ireland have significant problems that must be urgently addressed by Kidney.

Samoa, containing nine players from the Aviva Premiership and French Top 14, looked more dangerous when they abandoned the structured gameplan that blunted their attacking instincts and will view this as a missed opportunity.

The Pacific Cup holders' Haka was greeted by only a 30,955 crowd at Aviva Stadium with pre-match fears of another low attendance proving correct.

And the likelihood of many of the crowd returning looks bleak after another poor spectacle at Lansdowne Road, which was swept with rain all afternoon.

O'Gara settled Irish nerves with a penalty moments into the game but it was due to sound defence from Tommy Bowe that their lead was not immediately overturned.

A fine tackle saw Bowe fell Tuilagi as the Leicester winger charged for the left corner, thwarting a strong attack from Samoa.

Brian O'Driscoll ran down several blind alleys before knocking on, victim of some typically robust tackling from the South Sea Islanders.

It was a competitive, finely-balanced opening quarter that was lit up when Ireland broke from their 22 through side-stepping full-back Luke Fitzgerald only to eventually run out of options in support.

Their tails up, the Irish renewed the assault through their pack and were rewarded when a series of pick and goes concluded with Heaslip driving over. O'Gara converted.

Samoa's response was emphatic with a second penalty against prop Tom Court at a scrum enabling them to set up a superb field position.

A great pick up by fly-half Tasesa Lavea and rapid hands from Seilala Mapusua released Tuilagi, who came marauding off his wing to cross under the posts with Lavea converting.

Ireland's problems at the scrum continued, a five-metre attacking platform ending when referee Keith Brown decided Hayes was guilty of collapsing.

With five minutes of the half remaining Ireland worked their way back into the opposition 22 and, spying acres of space on the left, O'Gara expertly changed the points of attack but ruined his quick thinking with a stray pass to Paddy Wallace.

Samoa lacked urgency at times with their poor kicking foiling attempts to break from their 22.

The start of the second half saw some anxious moments for Ireland as Samoa probed close to their line.

The constant drizzle had made the ball slippery and this undermined the tourists on two occasions, the second seeing openside Manaia Salavea spill forward when 10 metres from the line.

But now it was Ireland who could not escape their 22 with their backpedalling scrum causing almighty problems.

O'Driscoll eventually cleared the ball but Samoa were soon back on the offensive, ignoring one clear overlap before reducing the deficit to 13-10 with Lavea's first penalty.

Any time Ireland attempted to build some momentum, they were met by a brick wall that more often than not sent them hurtling backwards.

Winger David Lemi was lucky to escape punishment for an elbow on Stephen Ferris after Samoa had been shoved backwards at a scrum.

For all their possession, Samoa were struggling to trouble the scoreboard, and this time when Ireland escaped their 22 they struck.

A quickly-taken free kick saw Stringer pass to O'Gara, who jinked his way over the line in the 66th minute before improving his own try.

The fight had all but drained out of Samoa, who sensed their moment had passed, but the South Sea Islanders' pride prevented Ireland from scoring again.

The scorers:

For Ireland:
Tries: Heaslip, O'Gara
Cons: O'Gara 2
Pens: O'Gara 2

For Samoa:
Try: Tuilagi
Con: Williams
Pen: Williams

Ireland: 15 Luke Fitzgerald, 14 Tommy Bowe, 13 Brian O'Driscoll (capt), 12 Paddy Wallace, 11 Andrew Trimble, 10 Ronan O'Gara, 9 Peter Stringer, 8 Jamie Heaslip, 7 Sean O'Brien, 6 Denis Leamy, 5 Devin Toner, 4 Donncha O'Callaghan, 3 John Hayes, 2 Sean Cronin, 1 Tom Court.
Replacements: 16 Rory Best, 17 Cian Healy, 18 Donnacha Ryan, 19 Stephen Ferris, 20 Isaac Boss, 21 Jonathan Sexton, 22 Keith Earls.

Samoa: 15 Paul Williams, 14 David Lemi, 13 George Pisi, 12 Seilala Mapusua, 11 Alesana Tuilagi, 10 Tasesa Lavea, 9 Kahn Fotualii, 8 George Stowers, 7 Manaia Salavea, 6 Ofisa Trevarinus, 5 Kane Thompsen, 4 Filipo Lavea Levi, 3 Anthony Perenise, 2 Mahonri Schwalger (capt), 1 Sakaria Taulafo.
Replacements:16 Tii Paulo, 17 Simon Lemalu, 18 Iosefa Tekori, 19 Afa Aiono, 20 Junior Poluleuligaga, 21 Gavin Williams, 22 Jamie Helleur.

Referee: Keith Brown (New Zealand)
Assistant referees: Jérôme Garces (France), Neil Paterson
Television match official: Geoff Warren (England)

  • Bookmark with:

  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • reddit
  • StumbleUpon

Comments

spike19 says...

Oh dear what a shocking display, samoa lost to connaght last week and ireland only just put them away. I hope they find their sparkle before saturday that way it'll be competitive otherwise its gonna be another run out training session like murrayfield. GO ABs

Posted 13:42 15th November 2010

maorihill says...

Dear Daatchi,

BoD - what of fantastic player, probably first choice back of the last decade, even in New Zealand and Kiwis are loath to admit anyone is better than them at footie! Last decade "yes", this decade "no". BoD no longer has any pace and is consequently ineffective in the outside centre position. His jersey should have been handed over to someone younger, 18 months ago. Of course this will not happen now - his captaincy for the RWC is probably in his IRFU contract!

Posted 07:59 15th November 2010

Daatchi says...

In fairness can we please give BOD a break. He first donned an international jersey for Ireland 11 nearly 12 years ago. That is some feat in my eyes. Especially for a centre. I do agree though that he just hasnt got the pace he once had and I think Kidney should stop running him ragged and let someone else into the 13 jersey now and again. Keith Earls needs the experience and Ireland needs more depth in the centres. Maybe they should use BOD as a coach/player and let him mentor someone else..

Maorihill - Im not so sure about a full strength SA in the 1/4s. They are in the same boat as the Irish with their own living gods at this stage. I reckon its definitley going to be France or Aussie that lifts the world cup next year.

Posted 22:29 14th November 2010

JeanLucJoinel says...

ireland were again shockingly bad.

Posted 21:49 14th November 2010

BlueLion says...

How about an unpopular simile to sum up the Irish performances in 2010...

Like the banks we can deny where this is going all we want. Ultimately the team is falling apart. It started in the 6-Nations. Wales were awful, which hid Ireland's poor performance. The last day in Croke Park against Scotland, and they lose. he tour was a dissaster. november is going to be a wash out, crowd sizes and results.

There is a great chance to blend the team with youth and experience. What a waste not to exploit it.

Posted 21:23 14th November 2010

Jondo says...

Clearly this Samoan side is very good, if more time together and i am pretty come world cup, this exact same starting 15 is playing for Samoa i'm pretty sure they will be pushing for a place in the quarter finals...

Posted 20:32 14th November 2010

eeiagm says...

crouch ... touch ............ pause ........................................................ whistle

Posted 17:08 14th November 2010

5Lock4ward says...

I would say everyone needs to relax. Ireland clearly didn't field their top xv today, note that Ferris was on the bench. Clearly they're more worried about their next game and did just enough to win. Samoa are a very physical team and you will know you played them when the match is over but until the Pacific Islands teams develop solid tight 5 players and learn to dominate the set piece, they'll continue to remain bruisers on the losing end of the ledger.

Posted 13:43 14th November 2010

boysinblue says...

@bluelion: Come on, you don't really think that? Give the man a bit of credit, I'm sure he picks what he thinks is the best team available to him.

@blackbeast: No, we're not the worlds best and we're not in the space of winning world cups, but then again, neither are your boys.

Posted 11:14 14th November 2010

maorihill says...

All too predicable - humble Samoa showing what heart and a little bit of talent can do.

These games are "final trials" for next years world cup. SA, Aust and NZ are testing future opponents. Their squads were chosen 18 months ago, old guards cleared out and the young bloods throw into the maelstrom. Just look at Australia! Ireland took a different approach. Let's retain all the old boys and bolster the provinces with South African frontrow and New Zealand cast-off backs. This approach has maintained Munster and Leinster in the Heineken Cup but has done nothing for our national side.

18 months ago, our grand slam and Lions heros should have been given a big party and put out to grass. O'Driscoll (B) , D'Arcy, Stringer, Hayes, O'Driscoll (M), Cullen should have been on that list. Players who are almost but not quite up to top class international rugby should also have told so and no longer selected. In this category is Leamy, Reddin and Buckley. And finally, the All Black principle of "three and out" should be applied, no matter how big your reputation may be, you are out. In this group are Kearney (No 1!) and O'Callaghan.

So far from fine-tuning the squad for the World Cup campaign, Ireland is slipping further and further behind the big 4 (NZ, SA, Aus, Fra). Just how far behind we are will be confirmed this coming Saturday at the Aviva.

The sad thing is that the wonder crop of young players confined to the 2nd ranks in the provinces for the last year cannot now be introduced into the Irish team in time for the world cup. No, we are stuck with our "living gods" till after the World Cup. The likely outcome is depressingly predictable: a couple of wins in the 6 Nations (Italy and Scotland), 2nd place in our group at WC (will never beat Aust in southern hemisphere) and gallant defeat to a full-strength South Africa in the 1/4 final.

Posted 08:58 14th November 2010

blackbeast says...

hey ireland, hope youre ready for com'ing next hihihihihi

Posted 21:52 13th November 2010

BlueLion says...

AWwful, awful, awful... Why persist with Hayes? He was so good for Ireland and not being allowed to retire with a bit of honour. Cut him loose Declan, for him.

Mike Ross needs a look. Leo Cullen needs a look too. The political dimension springs to mind when Declan is a Munster man and obviously pressured from HQ to keep picking his faithful reds in green jerseys.

Posted 20:44 13th November 2010

sebbb says...

It is hardly one bad game, he was poor in the six nations, average in the H-Cup and been a passenger in the Nov Internationals thus far. He is one of the all time greats but his decline is well pronounced. Centre is one of the few positions that we have depth in. Giteau is also waning a little but the difference is he is not reliant on pace that is so evidently not there anymore. His style of play is more enduring.

Posted 20:30 13th November 2010

Nicholas41 says...

BOD a spent force? You tell him. Ozz backs today, got nothing because they had little possession and defence right in their faces. Are they spent forces? BOD is still one of the best three/four centres in the world today. Gitto was labelled a spent force today, too. Imagine a team with two spent forces in the middle....

Posted 19:38 13th November 2010

Nicholas41 says...

Incredible that a quiet game rights off a player. If B

Posted 19:33 13th November 2010

sebbb says...

Truly dismal - not sure what Mike Ross has done to Kidney but as long as he ignored, we will continue to get taken apart at the scrum. It is sad but it seems BOD is a spent force a 13 - he needs to either move to 12 and give Trimble/Earls the outside berth or maybe look at becoming an impact player.

Without wanting to sound too condescending, Samoa should be applauded for their effort. Had they the time together of their Irish counterparts to work on their set piece and study their opponents, they would have won.

Posted 16:49 13th November 2010

Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Character Count : 0/1900

Forthcoming Fixtures
Fixture Details
All times are local
International Match
Saturday , December 4
Barbarians vs South Africa 14:30
More International Match fixtures
Aviva Premiership
Friday , December 3
Sale vs Gloucester 19:45
Newcastle vs Bath 20:00
Saturday , December 4
London Irish vs Leicester 14:30
Sunday , December 5
Saracens vs Harlequins 14:15
Wasps vs Exeter 15:00
Leeds Carnegie vs Northampton 15:00
More Aviva Premiership fixtures
Top 14
Saturday , December 4
Clermont Auvergne vs Toulouse 14:30
Brive vs Agen 14:30
Castres vs Perpignan 14:30
Racing Metro Paris vs Stade Francais 14:30
Bourgoin vs Biarritz 14:30
Bayonne vs La Rochelle 14:30
Toulon vs Montpellier 14:30
More Top 14 fixtures
The Magners League
Friday , December 3
Connacht vs Aironi Rugby 19:00
Scarlets vs Leinster 19:05
Ulster vs Newport-Gwent D'gons 19:05
Glasgow vs Benetton Treviso 19:30
Saturday , December 4
Ospreys vs Edinburgh 18:30
Munster vs Cardiff Blues 19:30
More The Magners League fixtures
Recent Results
Fixture Details
All times are local
International Match
Sunday , November 28
Ireland 29 - 9 Argentina Ireland vs Argentina Report
More International Match results
Aviva Premiership
Harlequins 51 - 18 Leeds Carnegie
More Aviva Premiership results
The Magners League
Ospreys 19 - 15 Leinster
More The Magners League results
International Match
Saturday , November 27
Italy 24 - 16 Fiji Italy vs Fiji Report
England 11 - 21 South Africa England vs South Africa Report
Scotland 19 - 16 Samoa Scotland vs Samoa Report
Wales 25 - 37 New Zealand
France 16 - 59 Australia France vs Australia Report
More International Match results
Aviva Premiership
Leicester 44 - 19 Newcastle Leicester vs Newcastle Report
Exeter 24 - 19 Sale Exeter vs Sale Report
Bath 6 - 11 Wasps Bath vs Wasps Report
Gloucester 19 - 13 Saracens Gloucester vs Saracens Report
More Aviva Premiership results
The Magners League
Cardiff Blues 38 - 6 Glasgow Cardiff Blues vs Glasgow Report
Aironi Rugby 17 - 34 Scarlets Aironi Rugby vs Scarlets Report
More The Magners League results
Aviva Premiership
Friday , November 26
Northampton 35 - 23 London Irish Northampton vs London Irish Report
More Aviva Premiership results
The Magners League
Benetton Treviso 9 - 19 Ulster Benetton Treviso vs Ulster Report
Edinburgh 24 - 19 Connacht Edinburgh vs Connacht Report
Newport-Gwent D'gons 20 - 6 Munster
More The Magners League results
Aviva Premiership
Sunday , November 21
Wasps 33 - 25 London Irish Wasps vs London Irish Report
Newcastle 12 - 6 Gloucester Newcastle vs Gloucester Report
Bath 13 - 17 Saracens Bath vs Saracens Report
More Aviva Premiership results
The Magners League
Cardiff Blues 15 - 37 Ulster Cardiff Blues vs Ulster Report
Munster 27 - 26 Scarlets Munster vs Scarlets Report
More The Magners League results
International Match
Saturday , November 20
Italy 14 - 32 Australia Italy vs Australia Report
Ireland 18 - 38 New Zealand Ireland vs New Zealand Report
More International Match results
RBS Six Nations Table
Pos Team P Pts
1 France 5 10
2 Ireland 5 6
3 England 5 5
4 Wales 5 4
5 Scotland 5 3
6 Italy 5 2