Planet Rugby

  • The Best in 2010

    The IRB have announced the nominees the 2010 Player of the year award.

  • Missing Men

    Can you guess England's class of 2006 that won 23-21 against South Africa..?

  • November Tests

    Get all the news, views and interviews from the end-of-year tours.

  • Loose Pass

    The latest edition of our weekly column about all things rugby...

Boks hold on for victory

13th November 2010 13:05

  • Email
    • Add to del.icio.usDelicious
    • Add to DiggDigg
    • Add to Redditreddit
    • Add to FacebookFacebook
    • Add to StumbleUponStumbleUpon
ruan pienaar south africa v Wales

Tight finish: SA keep Wales out for second win on the road

Defence was the order of the day in the last five minutes at the Millenium Stadium as South Africa held on to beat Wales 29-25 on Saturday.

Needing a try to snatch victory, Wales laid siege to the South African line in the closing stages, going through some 15 phases of possession in injury-time, but some superb defence kept them at bay as the Springboks made it two wins from two games on European soil.

As hard as they tried, Wales were left to rue yet another defeat at the hands of their southern hemisphere visitors who at one stage looked dead and buried before staging a spirited fightback.

Up 17-3 in the first half, the Welsh looked a sure bet at ending their eleven-match losing drought over Tri-Nations opposition. But the boot of Morne Steyn (19 points) coupled with tries to debutant Willem Alberts and captain Victor Matfield in the second half, set up a thrilling finish that ultimately ended in heart-break for Wales.

In a game of two halves, Wales were worthy 17-9 leaders at half-time after getting the better of the sluggish world champions who looked a far cry from the team that dismantled the Irish only a week ago and were somewhat fortunate to head in just eight points down at the interval.

It got better for South Africa after the break, with their two quick-fire tries in the space of three minutes proving to be the deciding factor in this nail-biter of a Test.

The Boks got the start they were looking for, after Wales were penalised for entering the ruck from an offsides position and Morne Steyn's boot did the rest - three points to South Africa after just two minutes played.

However, that would be the last we would see of the visitors for the first quarter of the match as Wales hit back in emphatic fashion with two converted tries during a dominant 20 minute spell.

The first was just reward for the Welsh after turning down three points for a line-out eight meters out from South Africa's line. Alun-Wyn Jones did the business in the air, the ball went through the backs, Tom Shanklin seemed to obstruct a Bok tackler and George North went under the posts for a try on debut.

Stephen Jones added the extras from bang in front, and the shell-shocked Springboks strolled back for the restart. Ten minutes later, South Africa resumed their place under the posts to watch another Jones conversion sail between the uprights after James Hook got himself on the scoresheet.

Morne Steyn responded by landing his second penalty, with Andy Powell somewhat harshly penalised for going off his feet at a tackle.

But with Wales on the front foot and dominating both territory and possession, an increasingly ragged Springbok outfit paid for their indiscipline. Although Hook saw a penalty attempt from inside his own half drift just wide, Jones made no mistake from closer range after Deon Stegmann was pinged for an infringement at a ruck.

But it was the South Africans who finished the half the stronger as Wales were forced to desperately defend their line. The Springboks should have gone over for a try but, having wasted a clear chance to score out wide, they had to settle for a third penalty from Steyn to make the half-time score 17-9.

That lead was quickly extended to 20-9 after the restart when Bismarck du Plessis was called for trying to play the ball while on the floor, allowing Jones to kick his second penalty.

But from a position of apparent power, Wales suddenly found themselves on the back foot as the South Africans finally roused themselves to demonstrate just why they are the current world champs.

Bryne was penalised for not rolling away allowing Steyn to kick his fourth penalty and the Springboks then came alive with their two tries in three minutes.

After sustained pressure, the Welsh line was finally breached when substitute Alberts crashed over from close range out wide - Steyn adding a fine conversion to bring the visitors back within one at 20-19.

They then hit the front as captain Matfield went over to mark his record-breaking 103rd cap. Having worked the ball from right to left, the Wales defence was left horribly exposed when the South Africans quickly moved the ball back the other way and Matfield, up in the line, careered over despite the attention of two would-be tacklers - Steyn added the extras.

A frantic five-minute period was capped by North who, alone in oceans of space on the right wing, was spotted by Stephen Jones, the young winger collecting an astute cross-field kick from his fly-half to drop over the line for his second try.

But Jones was unable to add the conversion and South Africa's slender lead was stretched to four points with 16 minutes remaining when Wales' backs were caught offside at a maul handing Steyn a simple penalty chance in front of posts.

Steyn increased his side's lead, but Wales finished the match camped just metres from South Africa's tryline, rumbling on through their forwards for repeated phases before the Springboks finally - and with a huge sigh of relief - shut up shop.

Man of the match: The 18-year-old giant Wales wing George North, who has already been dubbed the Welsh Jonah Lomu, matched his billing with a barnstorming display.

Moment of the match: Wales' last-gasp effort at the end - anyone watching will no doubt have shorter nails and less hair for it.

Villain of the match: No cards. But perhaps Wales were their own worst enemies for letting the Boks back in the match in what could have been a memorable Welsh victory.

The scorers:

For Wales:
Tries: North 2, Hook
Cons: S Jones 2
Pens: S Jones 2

For South Africa:
Tries: Alberts, Matfield
Cons: M Steyn 2
Pens: M Steyn 5

Wales: 15 Lee Byrne, 14 George North, 13 Tom Shanklin, 12 James Hook, 11 Shane Williams, 10 Stephen Jones, 9 Mike Phillips, 8 Jonathan Thomas, 7 Martyn Williams, 6 Andy Powell, 5 Bradley Davies, 4 Alun-Wyn Jones, 3 Adam Jones, 2 Matthew Rees, 1 Paul James.
Replacements: 16 Huw Bennett, 17 John Yapp, 18 Ryan Jones, 19 Deiniol Jones, 20 Richie Rees, 21 Andrew Bishop, 22 Chris Czekaj.

South Africa: 15 Gio Aplon, 14 Bjorn Basson, 13 Frans Steyn, 12 Jean de Villiers, 11 Bryan Habana, 10 Morne Steyn, 9 Ruan Pienaar, 8 Pierre Spies, 7 Juan Smith, 6 Deon Stegmann, 5 Victor Matfield (capt), 4 Bakkies Botha, 3 Jannie du Plessis, 2 Bismarck du Plessis, 1 Tendai Mtawarira,
Replacements: 16 Chiliboy Ralepelle, 17 CJ van der Linde, 18 Flip van der Merwe, 19 Willem Alberts, 20 Francois Hougaard, 21 Zane Kirchner, 22 Patrick Lambie.

Referee: Steve Walsh (Australia)

By Dave Morris

  • Bookmark with:

  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • reddit
  • StumbleUpon

Comments

MarcoP says...

Where to start? Brian Moore is an incompetent, irritating, biased "commentator". High time that the BBC got rid of him.

And Steve Walsh, the referee... maybe the two of them could create a new sport with no defined rule whatsoever? Because that's the impression Walsh gives... "I'll blow when I want to, if I want to, for no reason, and let everything else go". Hadn't he been banned already?

Posted 15:40 17th November 2010

jones says...

I'm a club ref and I agree with the comments about Brian Moore. His knowledge of the rules and general commentary is shocking. How he keeps is job is beyond me.

Posted 11:47 15th November 2010

danut says...

As a kiwi fan imagine how glad I am that the saffas were lucky two weeks in a row and Pidyvy stays put....

But of course no Grand Slam because England are waiting!!!!

Posted 18:38 14th November 2010

smarty says...

Yea I love the attritional power game with the forwards. Scrums, mauls, rolling maul, lineouts and toughly contested breakdown, pick and drive with the backs released after fowards are sucked in. SA are very effective playing this was and i love it. If I was looking for all passing I would put Os Durant and BEASSST in a pair of tight shorts and get them playing league and other rugby styles.

Having said that the Kiwi's do all of that and have sensational backs too. Pray for rain at the WC or we will get hammered.

Posted 14:28 14th November 2010

ruggafan says...

@Greg What are you on about? That match is the kind of match that makes us rugby fans enjoy the game. Full of excitment , no Foul play, could have gone either way at the end. Thank you welsh for a great game and for being gracious in defeat. Wish i could say that about the rest of the Fans on this site.

Posted 12:21 14th November 2010

scot_rsa says...

Looking like PdV will get the necessary 3 wins to save his skin (if his position was ever really in doubt). It ain't convincing stuff though and Boks have been lucky in many ways. Worst possible outcome for SA - poor performances but wins nonetheless therefore PdVGold/Muir stay. Depression.

Posted 12:13 14th November 2010

Meneer says...

Cardiff, the people the stadium is the best place in the world the experience rugby. I have been to support the Springboks there a few times now and I will be back for more. Welsh rugby is better than the results posted, last year the Boks were luck to hold out a narrow win and yesterday is not much different. Good luck Wales in the 6 Nations!

Posted 11:40 14th November 2010

dolgun says...

Steve Walsh is in love with himself. Constantly checking himself out on the big screen. Very avarage refeering today - glad he's no longer representing NZ.

Posted 07:30 14th November 2010

dafydd29 says...

Justice, as it happens I only saw the second half - French TV were due to show the Australia game (with a slight delay) - and didn't, so it was half time in Cardiff before I found a different TV. If Walsh was lousy in the first half as well that takes some of the pain away - but he still should be permanently retired.

Posted 07:07 14th November 2010

gregs says...

Boks escaped without their now customary citing/yellow/red - that is worth a remark - the rest I'm afraid left me cold. I've honestly seen less choreography in a Riverdance vs Morris Dance-off... It seems rugby union is now just WWF wrestling with a whistle ?

Posted 05:35 14th November 2010

frrersh says...

Incompetent ref from both sides point of view - 100% in favour of the attacking side no mater what infringments they made! Game changed then the boks came (extremely late in my opinion) to this conclusion and stoped giving possession away cheaply. SA need to come to the realisation that turnover rugby is no longer possible with the current interpretations and that posession wins games!

Posted 22:47 13th November 2010

redrhys2000 says...

An excellent match today, a very physical and hard fought encounter with an exciting finale. Sadly for us Welsh folk the end result was another disppointment. Nevertheless our team gave it's all against very strong and determined opponents and showed considerable grit and skill in the process. Seems to me that both teams and sets of supporters could lay some genuine complaints at the door of Mr Walsh but I do wonder if we would have had such a cracking match if he had been able to do his job properly. It is very ironic I know but sometimes bad officiating makes for a better game than one where the sound of the whistle throughout is deafening. Anyway , well done South Africa , enjoy your victory celebrations but remember our day is still to come.

Posted 22:01 13th November 2010

hayj05 says...

The Welsh backs looked really dangerous, it's a pitty Williams was injured. It's great seeing the Northern Hemisphere teams playing enterprising rugby. It's all shaping up for a cracking world cup in 10 months time.

Posted 21:42 13th November 2010

Bokswillprevail says...

Brian Moore has only one eye.

Posted 21:32 13th November 2010

Brett says...

When the boks play 80 minutes with ball in hand instead of kicking away possesion as in the first half they would then be putting sides as Wales away.

For once a intelligent substitution bringing on Alberts early

I to had the misfortune listening to Brian Moore,s ramblings,what a muppet!

Posted 19:16 13th November 2010

wellwellwell says...

Hats off to PR. You guys got this one right. What a game. Agree with Zambokke. I switched over to Afrikaans commentary as Brian Moore had no clue what the rules and application of rugby was about. Well done to the Boks. Dug deep and won it bravely, but when are you going to get it through those thick sculls of yours that when you keep the ball in hand you can match anyone. In this case pip the Dragons to the line. The Welsh were awesome and in my opinion the only NH side that will live with the SH sides. DOH, I believe England beat the Aussies. Come on England!!! Saying that, the Welsh play an attractive brand of rugby. Pace and power aplenty. Cheers to you!!!

Posted 18:02 13th November 2010

justice_4_all says...

@dafydd29 Yes he made some strange calls....but did you think they were one sided? What about obstruction during the Welch try? I thought that you guys played great rugby and deserved to win the first half....but please don't come prattling here about Bok tries that should have been disallowed and not mention the most obvious bad call....you are an embarrassment to the Welch who are fine sportsmen and fine rugby players.

Posted 17:54 13th November 2010

davefear says...

My goodness Habana had another shocker, all over the place defensively and nothing to offer on attack. 2 of 3 of Wales' tries were down to his defensive frailties (and lame reffing!). Notice how much better we were defensively when he was off the park in the last 10 minutes or so!

Posted 17:37 13th November 2010

Zambokke says...

I'm in the UK. Wow the BBC commentators are biased. Well done to the Boks. Too relaxed in the first half though. Too many mistakes and not enough commitment. Picked it up in the second half - well done boys, great effort. Can't afford to have loose tackling against England and Scotland like we did in the first half. The first Welsh try was a joke; should not have been allowed - obstruction not crossing. Hats off to them though; they fought hard. Wierd reffing Walsh! I'd love to know how their winger got 4 meters on our backs with that cross field kick - couldn't see on the BBC; was it off-side.

Posted 16:53 13th November 2010

Agreetodisagree says...

The Welsh gave South Africa a wonderful and moving rendition of our national anthem. Most countries butcher it. Wales you have grace, charm and are wonderful sports and South Africans love you. And the rugby was thrilling.

Posted 16:51 13th November 2010

Page 1 of 2
  • 1
  • 2

Character Count : 0/1900

Forthcoming Fixtures
Fixture Details
All times are local
International Match
Saturday , November 27
Italy vs Fiji Italy vs Fiji Preview
England vs South Africa England vs South Africa Preview
Scotland vs Samoa 14:30
Wales vs New Zealand Wales vs New Zealand Preview
France vs Australia France vs Australia Preview
Sunday , November 28
Ireland vs Argentina Ireland vs Argentina Preview
More International Match fixtures
Aviva Premiership
Saturday , November 27
Exeter vs Sale Exeter vs Sale Preview
Leicester vs Newcastle Leicester vs Newcastle Preview
Gloucester vs Saracens Gloucester vs Saracens Preview
Bath vs Wasps Bath vs Wasps Preview
Sunday , November 28
Harlequins vs Leeds Carnegie Harlequins vs Leeds Carnegie Preview
Friday , December 3
Sale vs Gloucester 19:45
Newcastle vs Bath 20:00
More Aviva Premiership fixtures
The Magners League
Saturday , November 27
Cardiff Blues vs Glasgow 13:30
Aironi Rugby vs Scarlets Aironi Rugby vs Scarlets Preview
Sunday , November 28
Ospreys vs Leinster Ospreys vs Leinster Preview
Friday , December 3
Connacht vs Aironi Rugby 19:00
Scarlets vs Leinster 19:05
Ulster vs Newport-Gwent D'gons 19:05
Glasgow vs Benetton Treviso 19:30
More The Magners League fixtures
Recent Results
Fixture Details
All times are local
Aviva Premiership
Friday , November 26
Northampton 35 - 23 London Irish Northampton vs London Irish Report
More Aviva Premiership results
The Magners League
Benetton Treviso 9 - 19 Ulster Benetton Treviso vs Ulster Report
Edinburgh 24 - 19 Connacht Edinburgh vs Connacht Report
Newport-Gwent D'gons 20 - 6 Munster
More The Magners League results
Aviva Premiership
Sunday , November 21
Wasps 33 - 25 London Irish Wasps vs London Irish Report
Newcastle 12 - 6 Gloucester Newcastle vs Gloucester Report
Bath 13 - 17 Saracens Bath vs Saracens Report
More Aviva Premiership results
The Magners League
Cardiff Blues 15 - 37 Ulster Cardiff Blues vs Ulster Report
Munster 27 - 26 Scarlets Munster vs Scarlets Report
More The Magners League results
International Match
Saturday , November 20
Italy 14 - 32 Australia Italy vs Australia Report
Scotland 21 - 17 South Africa Scotland vs South Africa Report
Ireland 18 - 38 New Zealand Ireland vs New Zealand Report
England 26 - 13 Samoa England vs Samoa Report
France 15 - 9 Argentina France vs Argentina Report
More International Match results
Aviva Premiership
Exeter 15 - 9 Leeds Carnegie Exeter vs Leeds Carnegie Report
More Aviva Premiership results
International Match
Friday , November 19
Wales 16 - 16 Fiji Wales vs Fiji Report
More International Match results
Aviva Premiership
Sale 10 - 19 Northampton Sale vs Northampton Report
Leicester 18 - 13 Harlequins Leicester vs Harlequins Report
More Aviva Premiership results
The Magners League
Connacht 15 - 16 Ospreys Connacht vs Ospreys Report
Leinster 27 - 6 Newport-Gwent D'gons Leinster vs Newport-Gwent D
More The Magners League results
LV= Cup
Sunday , November 14
London Irish 16 - 25 Scarlets London Irish vs Scarlets Report
Wasps 18 - 16 Bath Wasps vs Bath Report
Leeds Carnegie 17 - 23 Sale Leeds Carnegie vs Sale Report
Harlequins 28 - 20 Newcastle Harlequins vs Newcastle Report
More LV= Cup results
International Match
Saturday , November 13
Italy 16 - 22 Argentina Italy vs Argentina Report
More International Match results
RBS Six Nations Table
Pos Team P Pts
1 France 5 10
2 Ireland 5 6
3 England 5 5
4 Wales 5 4
5 Scotland 5 3
6 Italy 5 2

Special Feature

Special Feature Image

Pumas and Gear for Tipster

The last weekend of November is upon us and that means one more bumper Saturday of Test fixtures to mull over for the Tipster.